How to review a scientific article

There is a wonderful article on how to review by Hoppin: How I Review an Original Scientific Article.

It’s quite worth being read in its entirety. One point: He suggests that if there are potential fatal flaws, contact the authors and give them a chance to explain themselves. That’s only if there is an official response phase in the process, which isn’t the norm for conferences.

Last changed by admin on 21 April 2009